Get ready for a monstrously delicious treat that’s more cute than creepy! These Pizza Monster Sandwiches, featuring crispy chicken nuggets and gooey mozzarella cheese grilled on savory garlic bread, are an absolute blast to make and even more fun to devour. Perfect for Halloween parties or a special family meal, they’re truly a mouthful of joy!

Contents

Embracing the Spooky Spirit: Halloween Traditions and Family Fun

There’s something uniquely magical about Halloween, isn’t there? As a child, I eagerly anticipated it each year, and that excitement hasn’t faded. To this day, accompanying our children on their trick-or-treating adventures remains a cherished tradition. I love strolling through neighborhoods as the crisp autumn air rustles through crunchy, multi-colored leaves underfoot. We watch in delight as the kids dash from door to door, admiring the creative pumpkin carvings and imaginative decorations adorning every porch. And who could forget the satisfying weight of that pillowcase, brimming with candy, and the ultimate thrill of dumping it all onto the living room floor to meticulously sort through the bounty and count our favorite treats?

Beyond the candy and costumes, another integral part of our family’s holiday traditions involves revisiting classic Peanuts movies. I honestly believe I could recite them word-for-word! My children adore them just as much as my brother and I did when we were their age. I can still vividly picture us, curled up on the floor in front of the television, each clutching our beloved stuffed Snoopy, completely immersed in Charlie Brown’s world.

^^ Love It? Pin It! ^^

The timeless appeal of Peanuts is undeniable, and my kids (and frankly, my husband and I too!) were incredibly excited about the new PEANUTS MOVIE when it premiered. There’s a universal charm in rooting for an underdog like Charlie Brown, isn’t there? It always feels so good! When you think of the Peanuts gang, do you have a favorite character? For me, it was always Snoopy. What a crazy, lovable beagle!

The Secret Ingredient for Fun: Tyson Chicken Nuggets

Speaking of family favorites, Tyson Foods was an official partner with THE PEANUTS MOVIE, and it’s easy to see why. Their chicken nuggets and chicken strips are a staple in many households, including ours. They make for a fantastic dinner solution, a quick snack, or even the perfect finger food for movie night. You can conveniently swing by your local Sam’s Club and pick up a generous 5-pound bag of Tyson Chicken Nuggets or Chicken Strips – that’s certainly enough to Feed Your Whole Gang! Tyson chicken nuggets are renowned for being fully cooked, made with 100% all-natural ingredients, and packing a solid 12 grams of protein per serving. Their inherent appeal to kids and ease of preparation make them an ideal base for countless creative culinary endeavors, like our spooky Halloween sandwiches.

One recent evening, we decided to have some extra fun with our Tyson chicken nuggets and transformed them into these absolutely adorable Pizza Monster Sandwiches! The experience of making them was just as enjoyable as seeing the finished, delightfully goofy creations. But the best part? They are incredibly delicious, marrying classic pizza flavors with the satisfying crunch of chicken nuggets.

Crafting Your Own Pizza Monster Sandwiches: A Simple Guide

Creating these delightful monsters is much simpler than you might think, making it a perfect activity to involve little helpers in the kitchen. Here’s a detailed look at what you’ll need and how to bring these fun sandwiches to life.

Ingredients You’ll Need for One Pizza Monster Sandwich:

2 slices of your favorite bread (Italian bread works wonderfully)
4-5 Tyson chicken nuggets (depending on bread size), or a chicken patty for a larger monster
2 slices of mozzarella cheese
2 large slices of pepperoni
Marinara sauce (your favorite pizza sauce)
Garlic butter (homemade or store-bought)
2 large green olives
2 toothpicks

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make a Pizza Monster:

The beauty of these sandwiches lies in their straightforward assembly. You start with prepared Tyson chicken nuggets, a good quality loaf of bread, some savory garlic butter, melty mozzarella cheese, rich pizza sauce, and classic pepperoni. Here’s how it all comes together:

**Prepare Your Nuggets:** Begin by cooking your Tyson chicken nuggets according to the package instructions. While they are baking or frying, take this time to prepare your garlic butter (if making from scratch) and gather all your other ingredients, ensuring they are within easy reach for assembly.
**Craft the Garlic Bread Base:** Generously butter both sides of each slice of bread with your garlic butter. Then, grill the bread on a hot griddle or skillet until it’s beautifully golden brown and crispy, much like preparing Texas toast. This forms the delicious and sturdy base of your monster.
**Assemble Your Monster:** Once the garlic bread is ready and still warm, remove it from the griddle. Lay one slice down. Spread a generous layer of marinara sauce over it – this will be your monster’s “blood”! Next, arrange 4-5 cooked chicken nuggets on top (adjusting the number based on the size of your bread). Carefully place two slices of mozzarella cheese on top of the nuggets, staggering them slightly so they peek out like sharp monster “fangs.” Add two large slices of pepperoni on top of the cheese, which will serve as the monster’s playful “mouth.” Finally, crown your creation with the second slice of garlic bread.
**Melt and Serve:** Return the assembled sandwich briefly to the griddle for a minute or two, just long enough for the cheese to melt slightly and all the components to warm through. This helps everything meld together into a cohesive, delicious bite.
**Add the Eyeballs:** For the finishing touch, take two green olives and carefully push a toothpick through each one. Then, stick these “eyeballs” into the top slice of bread.
**Behold and Enjoy:** Serve these incredibly fun Pizza Monster Sandwiches immediately! Watching the kids’ faces light up with smiles when they see these adorable creations is the best reward.

Helpful Tips for Perfect Monster Sandwiches:

**Fangs Positioning:** When placing the mozzarella cheese, ensure the two slices are positioned so they slightly part on either side of the nuggets, creating the most convincing “fangs” effect.
**Garlic Butter Hack:** To save time, feel free to use pre-made garlic bread. However, the homemade garlic butter recipe is simple and adds an extra layer of freshness and flavor. The quantity provided in the recipe below is perfect for approximately six sandwiches, so you can easily scale up for a party!
**Customization:** Don’t hesitate to experiment! You can use different types of cheese for varied “fang” looks, or even add a sprinkle of Italian seasoning to the garlic butter for more depth.

Aren’t these Pizza Monster Sandwiches just so much fun?

Looking for More Kid-Friendly Halloween Food Ideas?

If you’re planning a full Halloween feast, these monster sandwiches are just the beginning! Here are a few more spooky and delicious recipes to complete your spread:

Monster Pops
Witch Hats
Zombie Fingers
Mummy Meatloaf

Discover All My Halloween Recipes Here!

I guarantee your little ones will be absolutely thrilled to sink their teeth into one of these festive sandwiches before heading out for trick-or-treating or as the perfect snack before settling down to watch the latest PEANUTS MOVIE! Have you ever “Peanutized” yourself? The moment I saw the link, I couldn’t resist playing around with it to see what I would look like as a Peanuts character. What do you think?

LIKE THIS RECIPE?
Don’t forget to give it a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ star rating and
leave a comment below the recipe!

Close up of Pizza Monster Sandwich on a green plate

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars (based on 1 vote)

Print Recipe

Pizza Monster Sandwiches

There is nothing scary about these super cute Pizza Monster Sandwiches, chicken nuggets & mozzarella cheese, grilled on garlic bread – A mouthful of fun!

Prep Time: 5 mins

Cook Time: 30 mins

Total Time: 35 mins

Course: Uncategorized
Cuisine: Italian
Keyword: Pizza Monster Sandwiches, Halloween, Kid-Friendly
Servings: 1 sandwich
Calories: 1943 kcal
Author: Michaela Kenkel

Ingredients

For the Sandwiches:

Tyson Chicken Nuggets: 4 – 5 per sandwich (depending on your bread size)
Bread: 2 slices per sandwich (e.g., Italian)
Queen sized green olives: 2 per sandwich
Sandwich sized pepperoni: 2 per sandwich
Mozzarella cheese slices: 2 per sandwich
Pizza Sauce
Toothpicks: 2 per sandwich

To make the garlic butter:

1 stick softened unsalted butter
1 1/2 teaspoons garlic salt
1/2 teaspoon parsley
(Whip all ingredients together until well combined)

Instructions

Prepare nuggets according to the package instructions. Meanwhile, prepare the garlic butter and get all of your ingredients ready to assemble!
Butter both sides of each piece of bread with the garlic butter and grill (like you would Texas toast) on your hot griddle until golden brown.
Remove from griddle and assemble sandwiches in this order: Bread on the bottom, then pizza sauce, then nuggets, then two pieces of cheese (staggered to look like fangs), then pepperoni, top with the other piece of bread and return to griddle to warm and let cheese melt slightly.
Stick toothpicks into olives and then into the top of the sandwich as eyeballs.
Watch the kids smile!

Notes

You can use pre-made garlic bread to save time if desired. The garlic butter recipe provided makes the perfect amount for about 6 sandwiches.

Nutrition Facts (per serving)

This is a sponsored conversation written by me on behalf of Tyson Foods. The opinions and text are all mine.