Crafting the Ultimate Holiday Cookie Platter: Recipes and Tips for Festive Treats
Elevate your holiday celebrations with a stunning and delicious cookie platter! Discover a curated collection of irresistible recipes and expert tips to assemble the perfect assortment of festive treats. Find everything you need right here to make your holiday baking dreams a reality.
The Art of Assembling the BEST Holiday Cookie Platter
As soon as Thanksgiving wraps up, my kitchen transforms into a festive bakery. The annual tradition of holiday baking commences, starting with treats that freeze beautifully and gradually moving towards those delicate delights best prepared just before delivery. For years, crafting elaborate holiday cookie platters has been a cherished ritual, and I’ve come to learn just how much these sweet gestures are anticipated.
This isn’t to boast, but rather to highlight the genuine joy these platters bring. I learned this lesson firsthand a couple of years ago when I significantly scaled back my holiday baking. I opted for smaller boxes for family and skipped the two massive cookie and candy platters I usually send to my husband’s office. The embarrassment was palpable when a long-time colleague exclaimed, “I can’t wait for your cookie platter this year! I’ve been looking forward to it all month!” It was a moment that taught me the true impact of these homemade treats. That was the only time I ever made such a mistake!
The Foundation: Classic Sugar Cookies
When you envision a traditional “Christmas cookie,” what springs to mind? For many, including myself, it’s the timeless sugar cookie. A holiday cookie platter simply doesn’t feel complete without at least one variety of these delightful, customizable treats. Their buttery sweetness and versatile nature make them an absolute must-have.
These Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies are the very ones my Mom meticulously baked every year. Passed down from my Aunt Vern, they were the only sugar cookies I knew and loved as a child. To this day, my mom still makes them for me annually – a secret stash I guard in my freezer!
Another beloved sugar cookie that joined my holiday repertoire is my friend’s Grandma’s recipe: Grandma Davis’ Frosted Sugar Cookies. I make these every single year without fail. This recipe yields exceptional frosted cut-out sugar cookies, perfect for decorating and adding a festive touch to any tray.
This past year, I discovered a truly sensational new favorite: Old Fashioned Sour Cream Sugar Cookies with Sour Cream Frosting. Their tender crumb and rich, tangy frosting instantly won me over. You can absolutely count on these making a prominent appearance on my holiday platters this season.
Adding Warmth: Delightful Spice Cookies
Every well-rounded cookie platter benefits from a touch of warmth and spice. The options for spiced holiday cookies are incredibly diverse, from classic gingerbread and gingersnaps to rich molasses, comforting snickerdoodles, and festive eggnog-flavored treats. I always make sure to include at least one or two of these aromatic varieties on my platters to provide a delightful contrast in flavor and texture.
My affection for gingerbread dates back to my childhood. My Aunt Ellen used to bake the most adorable tiny gingerbread men and women every Christmas. Later, my sister-in-law, Karen, shared her fantastic Gingerbread Cookie recipe, which remains her son Alex’s all-time favorite cookie to this day.
While I adore gingerbread, I generally forgo the intricate cut-out versions these days to maximize my baking time and create a larger variety of treats. Gingersnaps are a particular favorite of mine! Whether they are delightfully chewy gingersnaps or the satisfyingly crisp kind, there’s nothing quite like a spiced ginger cookie paired with a hot cup of tea on a chilly evening.
That is, unless you can combine the best qualities of a ginger cookie with a classic snickerdoodle! The result is a truly unique and addictive treat that offers both the warmth of ginger and the comforting cinnamon-sugar coating of a snickerdoodle.
These Frosted Eggnog Cookies present another fantastic spiced cookie option. They are wonderfully soft and chewy, with a flavor profile boasting nutmeg, cinnamon, and the distinct essence of eggnog, present in both the cookie and the luxurious frosting. They add a sophisticated holiday touch.
It’s always a good idea to include treats of varying shapes and textures on your platter. These spherical Mocha Rum Balls are perfect for that! Plus, they offer the ultimate convenience – absolutely no baking required, making them an ideal addition for busy holiday schedules.
Sweet Surprises: Homemade Candies & Fudge
To truly diversify your holiday assortment, always remember to incorporate a delightful mix of homemade candies and creamy fudge alongside your cookies. The key is variety, not just in flavor but also in color. A platter that’s entirely brown can feel monotonous; mixing in vibrant hues from truffles, barks, and other confections makes it far more appealing and festive.
My absolute favorite holiday candy has to be these Peanut Clusters! This cherished recipe comes straight from my Aunt Janette. They are incredibly simple to prepare, requiring minimal effort, and oh my goodness, they are unbelievably delicious – a perfect balance of sweet and salty crunch.
Truffles are an exceptional choice for holiday platters, adding a touch of elegance and indulgence. These striking Red Velvet Truffles were a special guest post by my youngest daughter, Josie, a few years back. Beyond these, I also love to include classic Oreo Truffles and decadent Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Truffles.
This Easy Graham Cracker Toffee is a permanent fixture on my holiday platters. It features layers of buttery toffee, rich semi-sweet chocolate, and crunchy pecans spread over crisp graham crackers. It’s incredibly simple to prepare, yet everyone absolutely adores its irresistible combination of textures and flavors!
These Sugared Pecans, coated with a sweet candy shell and infused with cinnamon and vanilla, are not only a delicious snack but also make wonderful homemade gifts or elegant fillers for any holiday cookie platter. Their festive aroma and delightful crunch are always a hit.
These Homemade Twix Bars are surprisingly simple to create, yet deliver an incredibly satisfying experience. They feature distinct layers of crisp Club crackers, gooey caramel, and a rich chocolate peanut butter ganache, making them a unique and highly popular addition to any sweet spread.
The Indispensable Fudge
A holiday cookie platter without fudge is like celebrating Christmas in June – it just doesn’t feel right! Fudge is an absolute requirement for truly capturing the spirit of the season. Its smooth, rich, and melt-in-your-mouth texture provides a wonderful counterpoint to crispy cookies and chewy candies, making it a beloved staple.
As sure as the holidays arrive, you will find this incredible Candy Bar Fudge gracing my cookie platters. Imagine, only three ingredients, and one of them is actual Snickers Candy Bars? Yes, please! It’s a decadent, effortless treat that everyone raves about.
This Eggnog Fudge is tailor-made for Christmastime. It boasts a wonderfully smooth and creamy texture, crafted with white chocolate and a subtle yet distinct eggnog flavor that is sure to charm everyone who tries it. It’s a festive treat that truly embodies the spirit of the season.
Refreshing Peppermint Cookies & Candies
Peppermint is, without a doubt, the quintessential flavor of the holiday season. What would Christmas be without its crisp, invigorating aroma and taste? I’ll begin by sharing two of my favorite minty fudge recipes, then continue on to explore my other beloved peppermint-infused delights that are perfect for any festive gathering.
This delightful Mint Fudge is so remarkably simple to create, you’ll likely wonder why you haven’t added it to your holiday baking list sooner! Its smooth texture and refreshing flavor make it a wonderful addition to any festive spread.
Remember that versatile candy bar fudge I mentioned earlier? You can easily customize it to create new flavor experiences, just like I did here by incorporating refreshing York Peppermint Patties. This simple swap transforms a classic into a festive minty marvel.
These Chocolate Mint Candy Cookies are another fantastic recipe from my sister-in-law, Karen. They are my niece’s absolute favorite and such a delightful treat. Imagine a chewy brownie combined with a rich cookie, then kissed by the refreshing essence of peppermint. These are a mandatory bake for me every single year, and thankfully, they freeze exceptionally well, allowing for early preparation.
This stunning dark and white chocolate peppermint bark is another treat I often prepare in advance, as it freezes beautifully and always adds an elegant, festive touch to any tray. I love to vary it, sometimes making a batch with dark chocolate on top and other times with white chocolate. Here’s a little tip: stock up on candy canes when they go on clearance after the holidays. You can then use them for all your peppermint baking needs throughout the following year!
Family Favorites: The Platter “Must-Haves”
Every family has those indispensable cookies that simply *must* appear on the holiday platter. These are the cherished recipes that evoke fond memories and satisfy specific cravings. I always strive to include everyone’s favorites, ensuring there’s a little something special for each family member and guest.
These delightful Almond Raspberry Thumbprints are an absolute “must-have” for both my oldest son and my youngest daughter. What’s not to love about buttery shortbread filled with sweet raspberry jam and drizzled with a light almond glaze? They’re simply irresistible.
My husband is particularly fond of Chocolate Crinkles. While I haven’t personally blogged about them because I typically use Betty Crocker’s classic recipe, I make at least a double batch every single year. Their soft, fudgy interior and powdered sugar coating are a holiday tradition we can’t miss.
For my youngest son, my oldest daughter, and her boyfriend, these classic Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies are an absolute essential. Their soft, chewy peanut butter base topped with a melted chocolate kiss makes them a beloved holiday tray staple that disappears quickly!
Explore ALL My Delicious Cookie Recipes
Discover ALL My Irresistible Candy Recipes
Expert Tips for Packaging & Presenting Your Holiday Treats
Once your incredible assortment of holiday cookies and candies is baked and ready, presentation is key to making them truly special. Thoughtful packaging not only protects your delicious creations but also enhances the gift-giving experience. Here are some ideas for how to beautifully package and present your homemade holiday treats:
- Large Trays: Ideal for festive parties, office gatherings, or big family get-togethers where you’re serving many people.
- Small Decorative Boxes or Plates: Perfect for gifting to couples, smaller families, or individual friends. These can often be found at craft stores or dollar stores during the holiday season.
- Charming Cookie Tins: A classic choice that offers both protection and a reusable keepsake. They’re great for shipping or for gifting to neighbors.
- Festive Treat Bags: An easy and economical option for handing out individual portions or a small variety of cookies. Look for ones with holiday designs.
The choice of packaging largely depends on the number of recipients and the occasion. For grander events like my husband’s office party or large family Christmas gatherings, I assemble expansive trays overflowing with a diverse selection. For smaller, more intimate gifts to individual families or couples, I opt for charming smaller plates, festive tins, or decorative boxes. My goal is always to ensure there’s a delightful variety, with at least one of each treat for everyone to sample and enjoy. While I often forget to capture perfect photos of my beautifully arranged platters, the joy they bring to others is always the greatest reward.
^^LOVE THESE IDEAS? PIN IT NOW!^^
Happy Holiday Baking to you and yours! May your kitchens be filled with warmth, your homes with laughter, and your platters with an abundance of delicious, homemade treats.
For even more holiday inspiration beyond cookies, consider these delightful popcorn and snack mixes: